Fishduck's all time Ducks top 10.... Do you agree?

Alan · Post by **Alan** » Wed May 11, 2016 10:35 am

I think he came up with a good list and I agree with 1 through 8, except I would flip Musgrave and Ngata. 9 and 10 could be exchanged by more than a few players..... Fouts or Chris Miller for example. Any thoughts?

http://fishduck.com/2016/05/your-all-ti ... l-edition/

DuckMastaFunk · Post by **DuckMastaFunk** » Wed May 11, 2016 11:50 am

I appreciate Musgrave's contributions, but he doesn't belong in a top 10 list. Top 25, sure.

UofDuck · Post by **UofDuck** » Wed May 11, 2016 12:18 pm

Fouts?

lukeyrid13 · Post by **lukeyrid13** » Wed May 11, 2016 12:19 pm

LMJ should be higher IMO. His years here were the years that took our program to the next level and gave us our identity as a fast paced spread team. Had he stayed another year, he would be in conversations about best college RB ever.

duckfan22 · Post by **duckfan22** » Wed May 11, 2016 12:32 pm

Fouts for sure... Kenny Weaton ?

Alan · Post by **Alan** » Wed May 11, 2016 12:34 pm

UofDuck wrote:Fouts?

NFL hall of fame, yes Fouts

maxduck · Post by **maxduck** » Wed May 11, 2016 1:31 pm

First team All American (both football and baseball) George Shaw, the #1 pick in the 1955 NFL draft, is not on the list?

buckmarkduck · Post by **buckmarkduck** » Wed May 11, 2016 3:44 pm

Neither Dixon or Musgrave deserve to be on the list. DD had 10 good games, and a bunch of mediocre ones. Adams might as well be on the list if that's all you have to do to be top 10.

I'd put LMJ up in the top 4, and reserve a spot very soon for Freeman. I'd also put DeFo on the list. It can be argued he had a better career at UO than even Ngata had.

buckmarkduck · Post by **buckmarkduck** » Wed May 11, 2016 3:47 pm

Alan wrote:
UofDuck wrote:Fouts?
NFL hall of fame, yes Fouts

The guy who threw more int at UO than TD?

Alan · Post by **Alan** » Wed May 11, 2016 3:58 pm

buckmarkduck wrote:
Alan wrote:
UofDuck wrote:Fouts?
NFL hall of fame, yes Fouts
The guy who threw more int at UO than TD?

Not even going to try to discuss this with someone who would eliminate a NFL hall of fame player for a great Duck running back (LMJ), LMJ isn't going to make many waves in the NFL. He did great things for the ducks but will and did not put the Ducks on the map like a Fouts or Moore. Defo does not belong there either until he proves himself. After further thought I do agree with you about Dixon and Musgrave. There are other players with a better impact for the Ducks than those two standouts.

buckmarkduck · Post by **buckmarkduck** » Wed May 11, 2016 4:04 pm

Alan wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:
Alan wrote:
UofDuck wrote:Fouts?
NFL hall of fame, yes Fouts
The guy who threw more int at UO than TD?
Not even going to try to discuss this with someone who would eliminate a NFL hall of fame player for a great Duck running back (LMJ), LMJ isn't going to make many waves in the NFL. He did great things for the ducks but will and did not put the Ducks on the map like a Fouts or Moore. Defo does not belong there either until he proves himself. After further thought I do agree with you about Dixon and Musgrave. There are other players with a better impact for the Ducks than those two standouts.

So the list isn't top 10 ducks? It's top 10 NFL ducks? You can drop 7 of those guys of fishs list right now if that's what you think. But since it's top 10 ducks, as in UO careers, fouts did very little at UO to put UO on the map. Unless you think Big Ben has put Miami of Ohio on the map.

Alan · Post by **Alan** » Wed May 11, 2016 4:11 pm

Go ahead and change my words to make any statement you want, LMJ was a great back that helped the Ducks greatly, but he's not a Dan Fouts. Fouts has Done more off the field to help the Ducks, post NFL, than LMJ ever will.... Unless he changes his ways....same with Blount.

buckmarkduck · Post by **buckmarkduck** » Wed May 11, 2016 4:22 pm

http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/pla ... uts-1.html

UofDuck · Post by **UofDuck** » Wed May 11, 2016 7:14 pm

buckmarkduck wrote:
Alan wrote:
UofDuck wrote:Fouts?
NFL hall of fame, yes Fouts
The guy who threw more int at UO than TD?

3rd round pick means he didn't suck.

buckmarkduck · Post by **buckmarkduck** » Wed May 11, 2016 7:33 pm

I never said he sucked, just that he's not a top 10 guy at UO. I'd bet he would say the same thing.