Did Anyone Else See The Penalty On UDubs Last TD?

[SuperDuck]

I haven't seen the replay yet, but I could have sworn I saw a Husky player pile on to an Oregon player in the backfield after he was already down. If the officials had caught that, the TD would have certainly been called back.

Did anyone else catch that?

[nogerO]

There were so many missed holding calls against the mutts it was infuriating. Pac-12 refs all need to be fired and Scott as well. What a joke.

[JIDuck97]

There were so many missed holding calls against the mutts it was infuriating. Pac-12 refs all need to be fired and Scott as well. What a joke.

It is getting worse rather than better with the officials. Hindsight after getting home from the game. Both targeting calls were correct and they had better angles than I saw in the stadium to call them. The holding was egregious by the pups and never called.

[woundedknees]

As much as CMC hates when the Ducks get stupid penalties, it's refreshing to see our coach step up to defend his players, especially in the face of egregious ineptitude that passes for PAC12 officiating!

Sure beats stoically grimacing on the sidelines.

Controlled, Focused, Anger... What a concept!

[Alan]

I just found a replay of the long browning pass for the huskies last TD, that was a blatant missed penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct by that UW lineman, within a few feet of the ref. ..... yet he didn't see it..... he was watching a touchdown! I'm 100% on the get rid of Scott and revamp the Pac-12 refs, the Pac-12 refs have been able to move from a joke to a embarrassing joke in one week.

[Duck07]

I haven't seen the replay yet, but I could have sworn I saw a Husky player pile on to an Oregon player in the backfield after he was already down. If the officials had caught that, the TD would have certainly been called back.

Did anyone else catch that?

It was Gus Cumberlander and he got held across the chest which slowed him down and let another OL come in to help before getting taken to the ground.

[SuperDuck]

I just found a replay of the long Browning pass for the huskies last TD, that was a blatant missed penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct by that UW lineman, within a few feet of the ref. ..... yet he didn't see it..... he was watching a touchdown! I'm 100% on the get rid of Scott and revamp the Pac-12 refs, the Pac-12 refs have been able to move from a joke to a embarrassing joke in one week.

I thought that's what I saw. Obviously, that could have been a game changer right there. I agree that the Pac-12 needs to seriously review its officiating crews.

Something else I think should be changed, I think all significant penalties should be reviewed. Either that, or coaches should at least have one "penalty" challenge flag per game.

[SuperDuck]

I haven't seen the replay yet, but I could have sworn I saw a Husky player pile on to an Oregon player in the backfield after he was already down. If the officials had caught that, the TD would have certainly been called back.

Did anyone else catch that?

It was Gus Cumberlander and he got held across the chest which slowed him down and let another OL come in to help before getting taken to the ground.

I didn't see the hold, only the Duck player on the ground and then one Husky DL pile on him. I'll have to watch that part of the replay.

Edit: I just watched the play again and I see the hold on Cumberlander. The personal foul happened after that and was from a different angle.

[JIDuck97]

I just found a replay of the long Browning pass for the huskies last TD, that was a blatant missed penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct by that UW lineman, within a few feet of the ref. ..... yet he didn't see it..... he was watching a touchdown! I'm 100% on the get rid of Scott and revamp the Pac-12 refs, the Pac-12 refs have been able to move from a joke to a embarrassing joke in one week.

I thought that's what I saw. Obviously, that could have been a game changer right there. I agree that the Pac-12 needs to seriously review its officiating crews.

Something else I think should be changed, I think all significant penalties should be reviewed. Either that, or coaches should at least have one "penalty" challenge flag per game.

Agreed on all counts.

[Duck07]

There were so many missed holding calls against the mutts it was infuriating. Pac-12 refs all need to be fired and Scott as well. What a joke.

It is getting worse rather than better with the officials. Hindsight after getting home from the game. Both targeting calls were correct and they had better angles than I saw in the stadium to call them. The holding was egregious by the pups and never called.

The problem I have with each of those targeting calls is that neither was an improper tackle or targeting the head/neck specifically. Sure, they were both hits that ended up high, but how many times does a RB or WR literally lead with the crown of their helmet and its never called and thats far more risky than either of those plays with QBs falling down while scrambling. There was no "launch" into the helmet even if contact was made and both players wrapped up.

I really feel like there needs to be an addendum that stipulates form tackling by a player can negate the targeting rule for when the player being tackled is falling. Or perhaps its just QBs, because I see plenty of helmet to helmet contact every game that doesn't involved QBs and there are practically 0 calls unless its a WR getting blasted.

As for holding, there were about 3 really bad ones where a Duck disengaged the OL and went laterally and you could see the jersey tug and nothing. Further, the hot mic conversation on the Kickoff Return early was quite revealing.

[buckmarkduck]

The TE on the big 3rd down play late, litterly pushed 39 backwards right in front of the ref, and no flag. Should have been OPI, instead they got a first down. We didn't just beat UW, we had to beat Scott and his goon refs also.

As for the targeting on UW, it shouldn't have mattered. The first guy tried to RIP Herbert's helmet off, should have been a facemask.

[Duckenstein]

Exactly right

They should have had a double 0ersonal foul on that play

The UW OL was egregiously holding on every play and they didn't call it once. Pretty ridiculous

The TE on the big 3rd down play late, litterly pushed 39 backwards right in front of the ref, and no flag. Should have been OPI, instead they got a first down. We didn't just beat UW, we had to beat Scott and his goon refs also.

As for the targeting on UW, it shouldn't have mattered. The first guy tried to RIP Herbert's helmet off, should have been a facemask.

[Alan]

Here's a link, I hope, of the missed unsportsmanlike penalty the OP was referring to currently it's the eighth video down, 29 seconds long, late hit by an UW OL on Duck DL.

http://www.espn.com/college-football/te ... egon-ducks

[TualatinDuck]

That's the one Alan. Austin is on the ground after the double team and the online jumps on him.

[duckfan96]

Saw a couple blatant holds on Jelks and Hollins...announcers at one point said oh that looked like a hold or something.