Page 4 of 5

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 2:43 pm
by ducks5ever
Jim Leavitt is the way to go! He will bring us back!!

Interesting takes on Tyree here. He did give Allen a nice helmet knock towards the end fwiw.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 2:47 pm
by buckmarkduck
Yeah iVe been as big of a Robinson "hater" as there's been over the years, but I've thought he's played really well so far this year.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 3:10 pm
by GrandpaDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:So grandpa youre giving Levitt bad marks because the previous staff wiffed severely on MLB? And then you give him no credit for at least moving Dye inside to halfway make up for that fact? Wht would you have him do, recruit one from another team? Because AJ has no awareness out there at all, the kid still looks lost half the time.
I did give him credit for poaching Dye. Just not for developing him, as he was a stud the day he walked on campus.

AJ is vastly superior to Apelu who was a black hole of production until the third quarter of the 3rd game in which he made his first 2 solo tackles in the run game. Prior to that I have seen him pancaked by both running backs and wide receivers when he tried to make a tackle, cast aside by opposing linemen with one hand while they were engaged with someone else. AJ has held his ground in the run game and taken down a ball carrier. But it's not AJ who I would play in front of him it's Swain.

Swain has barely played because they have him behind Dye who almost never comes out. In the less than one quarter against SUU he got to play he was very physical and productive. I suspect paired with Dye they could be the most productive inside pair we've had in a few years, but it appears we'll never know.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 3:13 pm
by Phenom
I've been calling for Swain for about 3 years now. lol

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 3:36 pm
by buckmarkduck
GrandpaDuck wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:So grandpa youre giving Levitt bad marks because the previous staff wiffed severely on MLB? And then you give him no credit for at least moving Dye inside to halfway make up for that fact? Wht would you have him do, recruit one from another team? Because AJ has no awareness out there at all, the kid still looks lost half the time.
I did give him credit for poaching Dye. Just not for developing him, as he was a stud the day he walked on campus.

AJ is vastly superior to Apelu who was a black hole of production until the third quarter of the 3rd game in which he made his first 2 solo tackles in the run game. Prior to that I have seen him pancaked by both running backs and wide receivers when he tried to make a tackle, cast aside by opposing linemen with one hand while they were engaged with someone else. AJ has held his ground in the run game and taken down a ball carrier. But it's not AJ who I would play in front of him it's Swain.

Swain has barely played because they have him behind Dye who almost never comes out. In the less than one quarter against SUU he got to play he was very physical and productive. I suspect paired with Dye they could be the most productive inside pair we've had in a few years, but it appears we'll never know.
You may want to watch the tape, because Hotchkins is terrible. At least Apelu is in the right spot, he just to small, slow and snot strong enough to make most plays.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 4:17 pm
by GrandpaDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:So grandpa youre giving Levitt bad marks because the previous staff wiffed severely on MLB? And then you give him no credit for at least moving Dye inside to halfway make up for that fact? Wht would you have him do, recruit one from another team? Because AJ has no awareness out there at all, the kid still looks lost half the time.
I did give him credit for poaching Dye. Just not for developing him, as he was a stud the day he walked on campus.

AJ is vastly superior to Apelu who was a black hole of production until the third quarter of the 3rd game in which he made his first 2 solo tackles in the run game. Prior to that I have seen him pancaked by both running backs and wide receivers when he tried to make a tackle, cast aside by opposing linemen with one hand while they were engaged with someone else. AJ has held his ground in the run game and taken down a ball carrier. But it's not AJ who I would play in front of him it's Swain.

Swain has barely played because they have him behind Dye who almost never comes out. In the less than one quarter against SUU he got to play he was very physical and productive. I suspect paired with Dye they could be the most productive inside pair we've had in a few years, but it appears we'll never know.
You may want to watch the tape, because Hotchkins is terrible. At least Apelu is in the right spot, he just to small, slow and snot strong enough to make most plays.
I have watched the entire games focusing specifically on the linebackers.

If AJ is in the right spot 50% of the time and can make a play, its better than being in the right spot 100% of the time and doing nothing but screening off players who might make a play.

But back to the point, I said Swain not AJ as my preferred upgrade.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 4:26 pm
by buckmarkduck
I'd love to know why Swain doesn't get a shot?

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 4:35 pm
by GrandpaDuck
buckmarkduck wrote:I'd love to know why Swain doesn't get a shot?
Why play him behind Dye? I just don't see how he could have been graded behind both Apelu and AJ and put in the spot in the 2 deep that gets no snaps. Let alone start at Mike.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2017 5:30 pm
by Groundswell
Swain looks the part, but he's always putting himself in the wrong place. I've never seen a linebacker run to the wrong side of the field as often. Only thing that makes sense is Leavitt doesn't trust him.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2017 6:08 am
by HomeSickDuck
Speaking of LB's, what about Simms? Haven't heard anything about him in a while. I know he was hurt not to long ago.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2017 7:45 am
by Groundswell
HomeSickDuck wrote:Speaking of LB's, what about Simms? Haven't heard anything about him in a while. I know he was hurt not to long ago.
He's out for the season.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2017 7:46 am
by StevensTechU
HomeSickDuck wrote:Speaking of LB's, what about Simms? Haven't heard anything about him in a while. I know he was hurt not to long ago.
He had knee surgery and is out for the season.

Next year's linebackers will look pretty different with Moi and Hotchkins graduating. Dye along with Niu/Slade-Mautatia, with Hollins & Winston Jr as starters. Backups will be Niu/Slade-Mautatia and Rugraff/Apelu inside, with Bryson Young and Keith Simms outside. I wouldn't be surprised if Simms moves inside, but for now they have him listed as an OLB.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2017 10:22 am
by ducks5ever
This just proves that we need to recruit more LB's. Adrian Jackson is going to be good, and Cunningham has good upside (along with our Georgia commit?), but we're walking on thin ice at this position this year and next year (at this rate)

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2017 10:25 am
by StevensTechU
ducks5ever wrote:This just proves that we need to recruit more LB's. Adrian Jackson is going to be good, and Cunningham has good upside (along with our Georgia commit?), but we're walking on thin ice at this position this year and next year (at this rate)
You left off Andrew Johnson, who perhaps has the most upside of any of the LB commits.

http://247sports.com/Player/Andrew-Johnson-46039756

Jonathon King is thickly built but very well ends up playing OLB, as well.

Re: Defensive improvement

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2017 12:03 pm
by buckmarkduck